Mortgage broker vs. direct lender: what’s the difference?


Mortgage broker vs direct lender: an overview

The mortgage industry is full of individuals and businesses helping people access finance for one of the biggest investments of their lives. These entities include mortgage brokers and direct lenders. Although they can provide services to people seeking mortgages, they are quite different. A mortgage broker acts as an intermediary in helping consumers identify the best lender for their situation, while a direct lender is a bank or other financial institution that decides if you qualify for the loan and, if you do, remits the loan. check.

Key points to remember

  • A mortgage broker brings borrowers and mortgage lenders together by acting as an intermediary between the two.
  • Direct lenders are financial institutions that approve and finance mortgage loans.
  • Brokers can help if you want to shop around without having to contact multiple lenders yourself.
  • A bank is a good place to start, especially if you have a good relationship with your financial institution.

Mortgage broker

When a potential homeowner is ready to shop for a mortgage, they may decide to consult a mortgage broker. It is a financial professional who brings borrowers and lenders together. They are not lenders and as such do not use their own funds to make mortgages. Instead, they act as middlemen, helping consumers compare prices, providing them with a variety of quotes from different lenders at once.

To do this, a mortgage broker sits down with his clients to assess their needs and their financial situation. They collect important information and documents that lenders demand from the borrower, including income, pay stubs, tax returns, asset and investment details, and credit reports. This helps them assess how much a consumer can afford to borrow.

Once gathered, they pass this information on to a bank or other lender for loan approval. Brokers are also responsible for communication between borrowers and lenders during the application and approval process.

A good mortgage broker should be able to provide valuable information, such as lenders who lend money in certain areas, those who offer a specific type of mortgage, and those who welcome or avoid loan applications for certain types of housing such as co-ops, condos or multi-family homes.

Mortgage brokers offer the convenience of being a one stop shop. This eliminates the need to visit multiple lenders to try and get the best rate and ultimately get a mortgage approved. And consumers won’t have multiple accesses to their credit reports since they’ll only have to visit one person to get the best loan possible.

Mortgage brokers do not make loans, but provide a one-stop-shop with access to multiple lenders, while a direct lender is a single entity that eliminates middlemen.

Direct lender

A direct lender is a financial institution or private entity that actually grants the loan for a mortgage. Direct lenders can be banks and other financial institutions. Some direct lenders are private companies that deal specifically with mortgage financing for the general public, many of which operate online. For example, borrowers who use lenders like Quicken Loans and Loan Direct can complete and get their approvals online.

Many borrowers choose to go to a lender they have done business with. Having a long-standing relationship can help get a better or larger loan amount, not to mention a better interest rate. The process for applying for a mortgage through a direct lender is the same as that of a mortgage broker: provide documentation, complete the application and wait for approval.

Consumers avoid middlemen by going to a direct lender. It can also speed up the loan process. Since the lender deals directly with the consumer, the two can communicate effectively with each other rather than having to rely on someone else to relay the messages. Thus, if a consumer has any questions during the application and / or approval process, they can approach the lender directly.

The goal is to find the direct lender with the best rate and have a backup if they don’t pass. But there is a pitfall in choosing a direct lender. Skipping a mortgage broker can mean going through the application process with more than one direct lender. Shopping like this can be tedious and time consuming. It can also mean that your credit score is affected if you apply to multiple lenders within a short period of time.

Key differences

Compensation is one of the main differences between mortgage brokers and direct lenders. Mortgage brokers are paid according to a fee schedule. In most cases, loan origination fees charged by the bank are paid to the broker.

This figure is based on the total loan amount, which may influence the advice and search for a broker. Like some commission-based financial planners, some brokers work primarily with, or have part of, certain lenders, which may inform the choices they offer you.

Direct lenders, on the other hand, are remunerated by various fees and charges. For example, if a consumer goes directly to a lender, that entity collects the loan origination fees. The lender also earns money on the interest charged on the principal balance, late fees and other related fees required upon closing. Consumers can get a reasonable idea of ​​how much they owe the lender in the Good Faith Estimate (GFE) provided by all lenders.

Special considerations

Consumers are under no circumstances forced to choose between mortgage brokers and direct lenders. In fact, they can call both to compare their fares and judge which route they want to take.

A bank can be a good place to start, especially for those who have good relationships with their own financial institutions. For people who don’t want to have to contact different banks, mortgage brokers are a better option. As mentioned above, some lenders work exclusively with mortgage brokers and some brokers work exclusively with specific lenders.

This can allow borrowers to access loans that they would not even have heard of otherwise. But it’s always a good idea to ask them what their rationale is for suggesting a specific lender.

Mortgage brokers once had a risky reputation, so it’s no surprise that many people are still hesitant to use them. They were poorly regulated and their remuneration was based on the nature and amount of the loan. Some have persuaded borrowers to choose subprime mortgages or borrow more than they really need. But increased regulation and consumer protection laws make it a good alternative for consumers who want someone else to do all the shopping and talk for them.

Mortgage Brokers and Direct Lenders FAQs

What are the advantages of working with a mortgage broker?

You will have access to multiple lenders, which gives you a good idea of ​​how multiple lenders will qualify you. This can give you more flexibility, especially if your situation means that you do not fall into a category generally recognized by lenders.

What are the disadvantages of working with a mortgage broker?

The fees can be a downside to working with a broker. Some mortgage brokers charge a fee to the buyer. In cases where the lender is covering the costs, it is important to make sure that you are not directed towards a more expensive loan, as it comes with a higher commission for the broker.

What are the advantages of working with a direct lender?

Direct lenders can make funding decisions quickly since they control their own lending criteria. This gives them more control over which clients get the funds they are looking for. Another plus is that many major direct mortgage lenders are licensed across the country, which means they can assist buyers in any state. When a borrower is looking to buy a home in another state, direct lenders can be a great source of help.

What are the disadvantages of working with a direct lender?

On the one hand, you have to apply individually with each lender. When dealing with direct lenders, there are no brokers to help you with document gathering and assessing your financial situation.

Another downside is the approval of your request. Direct lenders have their own subscription and loan conditions. If there are issues with your application that they cannot overcome, your loan application may be refused. If this happens, you will have to start a new application with a new lender.


Comments are closed.